Introduction
I've watched countless friends of mine in tech get blindsided by a tax bill they never saw coming. Picture this: You exercise your incentive stock options, feeling great about your financial future. Then April rolls around, and your accountant delivers the news that makes your stomach drop. You owe thousands in taxes on stock you haven't even sold yet.
Welcome to the Alternative Minimum Tax catch-22.
If you work in tech and have incentive stock options, there's a good chance your taxes are affected by what I call the cruelest quirk in the tax code. The AMT was created in response to public outrage in the 1960s over 155 wealthy individuals who paid zero taxes despite having high incomes. Fast-forward to today, and this "fix" has ensnared hundreds of thousands of hardworking professionals who simply exercised their stock options.
Here's the brutal reality: When you exercise ISOs and hold onto the shares, you create a tax liability without generating any cash to pay for it. The IRS treats the "bargain element" – the difference between what you paid for the stock and its fair market value – as income for AMT purposes, even though you haven't sold a single share.
New to AdvisorFinder? Welcome! Our mission is to help people make more informed financial decisions. Once you're finished exploring this topic, you might want to subscribe to our newsletter.
Understanding the Alternative Minimum Tax
The Alternative Minimum Tax operates like a parallel tax system running alongside your regular income tax. Think of it as the IRS's way of saying, "We don't care how many deductions you have or what your regular tax calculation shows – you're going to pay at least this much."
Here's how the AMT calculation works in practice. You start with your regular taxable income, then add back certain "preference items" that don't count in the standard tax system but absolutely count for AMT purposes. The biggest preference item for most people with equity compensation? That ISO bargain element I mentioned earlier.
Let me walk you through a real example that happened in July 2025. Sarah, a software engineer, exercised 1,000 ISO shares with a $5 strike price when the fair market value hit $30 per share. Her bargain element? A hefty $25,000 that gets added to her AMT calculation, even though she didn't receive a penny of cash from the transaction.
The AMT system then applies its own exemption amounts and tax rates. For 2025, single filers get an $88,100 exemption, while married couples filing jointly get $137,000. After subtracting the exemption, the remaining amount gets taxed at 26% up to $239,100, then 28% beyond that.
But here's where it gets interesting. The AMT exemption doesn't last forever. It phases out completely for single filers earning over $626,350 and married couples over $1,252,700. In that phase-out range, your effective AMT rate can spike to 35% – higher than the top regular income tax bracket.
If you want a deeper breakdown on AMT, we like this guide from Carta (not sponsored or affiliated).
Why Generic Tax Software Falls Short
Here's something most people don't realize: Standard tax preparation software often struggles with complex ISO scenarios. The calculations involve multiple variables that interact in non-obvious ways. Your regular income, other preference items, filing status, state of residence, and the timing of your ISO exercises all affect the final outcome.
This is why specialized ISO AMT calculators exist. These tools are designed specifically to handle the nuances of equity compensation taxation. They can model different exercise scenarios, show you the AMT impact of various strategies, and help you optimize your timing.
The best calculators let you input multiple variables: your current income, expected bonuses, other stock option exercises, RSU vesting schedules, and even anticipated changes in tax law. They then run projections showing your AMT liability under different scenarios.
The State-by-State Complication
Most people focus solely on federal AMT, but that's a mistake. A handful of states – California, Iowa, Minnesota, and Colorado – impose their own state-level AMT that can include your ISO spread. If you live in one of these states, you're potentially facing a double whammy.
California is particularly aggressive. The state's AMT can add thousands more to your tax bill, and unlike the federal system, California's AMT credit recovery is far more limited. I've seen clients move from California to Texas or Florida specifically to avoid this additional layer of complexity.
Strategic Exercise Planning
Avoiding AMT entirely is often impossible if you have significant equity upside. Instead, you can focus on managing and minimizing your AMT exposure while maximizing your long-term after-tax wealth.
One of the most effective strategies is exercising when the spread is small. This typically happens in three situations: early in a company's growth when valuations are still modest, during market downturns when stock prices temporarily dip, or immediately after a down round when the fair market value resets lower.
The key is staying below the AMT exemption phase-out thresholds whenever possible. Once you hit those income levels, your effective AMT rate jumps dramatically. For many people, it makes sense to exercise aggressively up to the phase-out threshold, then pause until the following year.
I worked with a client at a Series B startup who exercised his entire ISO grant when the company's 409A valuation was still relatively low. His total bargain element was only $15,000, well within his AMT exemption. Two years later, when the company went public, those same shares were worth over $500,000. By exercising early, he avoided tens of thousands in AMT liability.
Another powerful approach is splitting large exercises across multiple tax years. Instead of exercising 10,000 shares in one year and triggering massive AMT, you might exercise 2,500 shares per year over four years. This keeps your AMT exposure manageable and gives you flexibility to adjust based on changing circumstances.
Working with Professional Advisors
While ISO AMT calculators are powerful tools, they're not a substitute for professional advice. The most sophisticated calculator can't account for your unique circumstances, risk tolerance, or broader financial goals.
When you're ready to find professional guidance for your equity compensation planning, you want someone who understands the nuances of AMT calculations and can integrate them into your overall financial strategy. Use our assessment to find financial advisor options based on your unique needs, including experience with equity compensation and tax planning.
The 'right' advisor will use AMT calculators as one tool among many, combining the computational power of modern software with the judgment and experience that only comes from working with clients in similar situations.
Prefer to browse? Browse all financial advisors who specialize in equity compensation
Frequently Asked Questions
About ISO AMT Calculations
Q: Do I always owe AMT when I exercise incentive stock options?
A: Not always. You'll only owe AMT if the "bargain element" (difference between strike price and fair market value) pushes your AMT calculation above your regular tax. Many people with smaller exercises or lower incomes stay within the AMT exemption limits.
Q: Can I get back the extra AMT I paid on my stock options?
A: Yes, through AMT credits. When you pay AMT because of ISO exercises, you earn credits equal to the extra amount paid. You can use these credits in future years when your regular tax exceeds your AMT, often when you sell the shares.
Q: Should I exercise all my ISOs at once or spread them over multiple years?
A: Generally, spreading exercises over multiple years is smarter. This keeps you within AMT exemption limits and gives you flexibility to adjust based on changing stock prices and personal circumstances.
Q: What's the difference between federal and state AMT?
A: Federal AMT applies nationwide, but only California, Iowa, Minnesota, and Colorado impose additional state-level AMT on ISO exercises. If you live in these states, you could face significantly higher tax bills.
Q: When is the best time to exercise ISOs to minimize AMT?
A: Exercise when the spread between strike price and fair market value is smallest. This typically happens early in a company's growth, during market downturns, or immediately after down rounds when valuations reset lower.
Q: Can regular tax software handle ISO AMT calculations accurately?
A: Standard tax software often struggles with complex ISO scenarios involving multiple variables. Specialized ISO AMT calculators are designed specifically for these nuances and provide more accurate projections.
Q: What happens to my AMT liability if I leave my company?
A: Your AMT liability doesn't change when you leave, but you typically have 90 days to exercise vested options. Plan carefully - exercising right before leaving without considering AMT implications can create massive tax bills.
Q: How do RSUs and bonuses affect my ISO AMT calculation?
A: Other income sources increase your total AMT calculation, potentially pushing you into higher AMT brackets or phase-out ranges. If you're already in AMT territory due to other income, exercising ISOs might have minimal additional tax impact.